Showing posts with label Standard of Living. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Standard of Living. Show all posts

Tuesday, 21 March 2017

A trade off for monetary policy

Since the global financial crisis interest rates in the UK (and the US, Europe and Japan) have been at record lows. The aim was to boost Aggregate Demand and avoid prolonged recession and promote faster recovery. An interesting trade-off has been highlighted as a result of this policy.

The low interest rates have indeed maintained UK output, according to a Bank of England economist, but the low rates have meant firms that should have ceased operations have been able to survive. Around 1.5 million jobs have been protected according to Andrew Haldane.

Of course saving jobs was exactly what the Bank of England were trying to do when they lowered rates. The unintended consequence of this action was that it reduced the costs of poorly performing firms. Those who were not efficient enough to earn the profits necessary to repay loans at 'normal' rates of interest have been able to survive ('Zombie firms' according to Haldane).

The impact has been to allow low productivity jobs to survive and this has led to poor improvements in productivity overall, because the productivity figures reported are an average over the whole economy.

Productivity is a measure of efficiency. It records how many inputs are required to produce a given level of output. For economic growth to deliver higher standards of living a rise in productivity year on year is crucial. The UK has a very poor productivity record generally and the low interest rates since 2008 have allowed this to get worse.

Haldane says that he is happy to have seen 1.5 million jobs saved rather than 2% productivity growth. At least 1.5 million people and their families will be agreeing with him.


As this is an article about the UK as an example it is directly useful to IB students. However VCE students can see the example of how all policy has trade-offs and policy actions often have unintended consequences, such as supporting inefficiency to reduce unemployment.

Sunday, 13 November 2016

Free trade is the way to prosperity - but now it is under threat.

Donald Trump's election will provide a great many challenges, including a threat to the environment. The greatest threat will, however, be to free trade and so the prosperity and wellbeing of the whole world.

That might sound a bit dramatic, and I am trying not to be political here. The fact is that specialization and trade are the basis of all the gains we have made in the standard of living and anything that restrict that makes us worse off. This is a lesson known for many years and most persuasively put by Smith and Ricardo and refined by J.S. Mill and all economists working in the field since.

There are costs of free trade. The one that is presently causing people like Donald Trump to get elected is that some industries decline due to trade. For one place to specialize in a good or service others cannot. This means some people lose their jobs in industries which are uncompetitive. People so affected tend to be pretty unhappy about it.

Economists point out that while some industries decline, others grow and so resources in a country transfer from one industry to another. The result is improved efficiency in the allocation of resources and a higher standard of living for everyone. The costs of adjustment are temporary.

It's a difficult sell, but until now we have relied on the education, good sense and long term vision of those in government to do no more than slow transition and cushion the blow for those affected. Now we have people being elected who are happy to pander to those who shout loudly, but don't have the necessary perspective. Make no mistake if the free trade arrangements we have worked so hard to build over more than one hundred years are unwound we will all suffer.

There are many articles out there on this issue right now. Below is the Guardian's.

Thursday, 26 May 2016

A problem of supply side reform

France has an unemployment rate of 10.5%, far higher than other EU countries of similar standing (but not as high as the basket cases of Spain, Portugal, Italy and Greece). That France's unemployment has been consistently higher than the UK's and Germany's really should concern the French.

The charts below show the French and UK unemployment rates. They show that UK unemployment has been consistently lower than Frances and that the UK has recovered from the Global Financial Crisis while France has not. Yet these two countries are neighbours, with broadly similar populations and similar industrial/service based economies.

One explanation offered for this is France's inflexible labour market. The maximum working week is set at 35 hours, there are strict laws about when people can work, generous minimum paid holiday (30 days a year compared to Germany's 20) and employment protection which makes it very difficult for firms to let workers go.

The French government wish to relax labour laws so that while those in work might be a little worse off there will be more jobs overall. 

This is a supply-side policy and copies the process begun in their neighbour, the UK, as early as 1981. This type of supply-side policy is called deregulation. The hope is that the reforms will give firms greater flexibility, so they become more responsive to customers and profitable, and encourage them to take on more employees because there is less risk they become 'stuck' with staff they don't need.

This is being strongly opposed by French Trade Unions who are engaging in nationwide strikes.

The article below explains the policy changes and also suggests that this is a battle between those currently in work and those who would like to be, but can't get jobs in the current climate.

The data certainly suggests that there is something stopping the French labour market from working efficiently and that this will cost France economic growth and give the French generally a lower standard of living.


This article is more directly applicable to IB students, but VCE students also need to understand the nature of Supply-side policies and their effects and also the difficulties that can be encountered in implementing them. There is no doubt that creating a more flexible labour market is one aim of supply-side policy and it will result in lower wage rate, but higher employment in the short-run, while allowing higher long-run growth.


Friday, 8 April 2016

The problem with protection

There has been a surge in the popularity of ''economic nationalism" among politicians recently. Talk of tariffs to 'level the playing field' has become common in Europe, the US and Australia. It's a really dumb idea.

The arguments run something like this. "Imported goods are replacing domestic goods, our industries can't compete and that means they shrink or close leading to unemployment. We should put a tariff on imports to save jobs."

This thinking led to disastrous rounds of tariffs being imposed in the 1930's making the Great Depression much worse than it otherwise would have been.

Today Donald Trump wants a tariff to protect US jobs from China, there is a danger of a steel 'tariff war' and in Australia it's not just steel which raises the protectionist instincts of opportunist politicians.

Tariffs will raise prices and reduce imports. But the implications are much wider than this. While tariffs will be popular with those who might keep their jobs for a little longer they impose costs on the rest of the population, cause inflation and restrict growth, so lowering the long term standard of living.

The New York Times article below goes through the implications of the imposition of a tariff. This is an excellent analysis on the dynamic effects of a tariff and provides multiple evaluative points.


IB students will find this an excellent resource for evaluating tariffs and understanding how the simple tariff diagram is only a static analysis. VCE students will be able to apply this to the idea of placing a tariff on imported steel to protect Australia's unprofitable industry.

Wednesday, 6 April 2016

The carbon tax worked. Proof of what economists always knew.

Australia is a pariah for its callous disregard of the global warming crisis. While it is fashionable within Australia to believe that the government is acting in the best interests of Australia's standard of living the rest of the world looks on them as bigots.

An example of the extraordinary behaviour of Australia is the repeal of the carbon tax. Various reasons were given including 'it didn't work'. (The other reasons are beyond the scope of the space we have.)

Taxes work by raising the price of a good and so changing the relative price of the good. As a result some consumers move to relatively cheaper substitutes and consumption of the taxed good falls.

The practical difficulties of taxing a good like carbon are significant. Demand for energy is price inelastic and so small rises in price have only a very small effect on demand. Demand is inelastic partly due to the lack of substitutes, the fact that energy is a necessity and it takes a long time to be able to switch to alternatives. Therefore the effect of the carbon tax was difficult to detect.

The chart below shows the changes in electricity generation, coal's share of that generation and emissions. Notice this shows percentage changes in totals, not absolute amounts. This is much more useful in tracking the effect of the policy changes.


The chart clearly shows that coal's share of electricity generation falls after the carbon tax was introduced in 2012 and that emissions fell even faster. Since the carbon tax was scrapped in 2014 coals share of generation has risen and so have emissions.

It is important to concentrate on the economics rather than the politics of this policy. Taxes do work (a Pigovian tax - see a post form last month) because changing relative prices will alter the allocation of resources. The problem is that it does take time to work.


As an extra here is a chart of how each state was generating their electricity on 7th April 2016.
Brown coal is the dirtiest fuel in terms of CO2 emissions. 

This article is relevant to both VCE and IB students. It can be used as an example for IB students and an Australian environmental policy is required knowledge for VCE.

Friday, 1 April 2016

New minimum wage rates - good or bad for the British economy?

The UK today introduced a new 'National Living Wage' which is effectively a minimum wage. The UK already has a minimum wage, but that's 50p less an hour.

There is a great deal of support for this move, but also a great deal of opposition.

Those who support the 'Living Wage' argue that the present minimum wage is insufficient to provide workers and their families with a reasonable standard of living. This is where the term 'Living wage' comes from.

Those who oppose the move say that many workers will lose their jobs or be forced to accept shorter hours as employers cannot afford the higher wage rate. They suggest that the market won't support the employment levels currently enjoyed at the higher wage rate.

The economics of this can can complex, but the diagram below shows the most basic analysis.
 In the diagram above the free market wage rate is 0W* and 0N* hours of labour are hired by firms. Suppose that the National Living Wage (NLW) is introduced at 0WH. As this new NLW is above the market rate the effect on employment will be detrimental with hours of labour employed falling to 0Nd. Those who remain in work will, of course, be better off, but this is cold comfort for those who loose their jobs.

If the new NLW is imposed at 0WL then there is no effect on employment at all. Workers will continue to be paid the higher open market rate.

The BBC article below shows the situation is far from this simple. Here are a few considerations.

* There are people earning less than the new NLW. How could they be earning less than the free market rate (0W*) at present? Possibly because of an imbalance of power between employer and employee meaning the employer can exploit the weak position of such workers (perhaps in a non-unionised industry). In this case the employers are being forced to pay a fairer wage rate.

* If the new NLW is above the market rate how many workers might lose their jobs? This will depend on the elasticity of demand for labour and this in turn depends on the elasticity of demand for the product they produce (derived demand).

* Looking at the BBC article shows that different regions of the UK will see different proportions of the workforce affects receiving pay rises. The distribution of gains between regions will be very different therefore on real incomes and hours worked. Overall their may be an improvement in the equality of the distribution of income, this can be measured by the gini-coefficient.

* In the short run there may be job losses due to the higher NLW. In the long run the improved standard of living may result in high overall benefits to society (lower government spending, improved productivity etc.) 

There are many aspects of the introduction of the NLW to consider. Issues are rarely as simple as they first appear and further consideration often draws us to a different conclusion.


 This article is more likely to be useful to IB students than VCE. However VCE students can still look at it as an application of demand and supply analysis. For IB students the evaluation of a measure is very important and this needs to be based on analysis (explaining using theory). Ther are numerous ways the initial demand and supply analysis could be developed.

Monday, 25 January 2016

Tax reform is a current issue

The Australian government has a budget problem. It's not always the problem they claim it to be so quickly here are the key problems:

1. The government does not raise enough money.  All budgets are a balance between income and revenue. Presently there is a budget deficit because successive Australian governments cut taxes and allowed some groups to have tax concessions which are politically difficult to remove.

2. The population of Australia is ageing. This will lead to the need to higher government spending in the future on services such as health and on benefit payments, such as pensions. There is also the likelihood that the working population will shrink, meaning fewer workers are available to pay the tax needed to raise revenue.

3. Commodity prices are falling. Australia relies on commodity exports to maintain its standard of living. The collapse in iron ore and coal prices means both Australia income and government tax revenue is falling.

Therefore action must be taken to establish a guaranteed revenue stream for the government. Reforming Australia's appallingly complex tax system, which has many built is advantages for vested interest groups, is essential. Everyone agrees on this point!

Th problem for politicians is that they can loose support if they upset voters by asking them to pay more. Therefore they are reluctant to make the tough calls.

One suggestion is that GST is raised to 15%, making everyone pay more. There are pros and cons.

Pros: GST is difficult to avoid, you pay it as you spend. It is cheap to collect, firms do a lot of the work for you and raising the rate makes little difference to collection costs. People don't notice when they pay it, it's in the price, so you get fewer complaints.

Cons: The tax is regressive. That means that the burden falls more heavily on the lower paid (lower income quintiles/deciles of the population) and so works against the goal of equity. If placed on goods with external benefits (positive externalities) it makes market failure worse.

An additional point is that if not applied equally on all goods it changes relative prices. Therefore goods without GST become more attractive to consumers and more resources are allocated to them, with fewer resources going to taxed goods. (This is how taxes work!) However an inefficient allocation of resources can result while the government are trying to do the right thing.

The Treasurer, Scott Morrison, is struggling with all of this as he prepares his first Federal Budget. He is concerned, according to the article below, with the effect of GST on Education and Health. Both are 'Merit goods' and they have external benefits. We wish to encourage increased consumption of both, not reduce consumption through tax.


How Australia deals with the 'Budget crisis' is going to be a vital topic for VCE economists and a case study for IB students.

Questions.
1. What is the effect of raising GST on the distribution of income? (Goal of equity)
2. How does putting GST on health differ from putting GST on education? (Hint. Only private education will attract GST.)

Tuesday, 8 April 2014

The Standard of Living

Pretty much everything in VCE Economics comes back to the standard of living. What this means is a difficult thing to pin down.

What we do know is:

* GDP alone is a poor indicator.
* Real GDP per capita using PPP is a much better one, but misses critical issues.
* The Human Development Index includes important additional factors and can be used to compare and monitor changing living standards.

However there isn't a perfect measure as non-material living standards are very difficult to measure and very different across nations.

The Social Progress Index tries to monitor living standards using a wide range of indicators. Australia still does well, but comes 10th (rather than 2nd in some HDI rankings). The 2014 data is linked below and it is well worth a look to try and grasp what standard of living really means and what can affect it.


Monday, 7 April 2014

When is free trade not free trade?

Australia has 'concluded a free trade deal with Japan' and will sign another one with South Korea in the next two days. This is an important step forward, but isn't properly free trade.

In the eighteenth century Adam Smith, and in the nineteenth David Ricardo, showed that everybody gains from free trade. Economists have accepted this ever since. It is therefore astounding that any country retains barriers to trade in the twentyfirst century. However some do and so do Australia and Japan after this deal.

There is abolition of tariffs on some goods. Cars from Japan to Australia, for example, will fall from a 5% tariff to zero. But not necessarily all at once. Other tariffs are merely reduced, such as the tariff on beef from Australia to Japan, which was an eyewateringly high 38.5%  will be halved. A 19.5% tax is still huge as a barrier to trade.

Tariffs are not the only barrier to trade. Quota's used to be a popular way to reduce trade and the new deal allows an additional 20,000 tonnes of Australian cheese to be exported to Japan. Another popular barrier to trade is to extol the benefits of local products. Australia is a master of this is their 'Australian owned' or 'Australian made' propaganda.

The simple fact of the matter is that all trade barriers harm the standard of living of countries. What protection (or economic nationalism as it is often called today) does is raise the prices paid by consumers and protects inefficient domestic producers from competition. Competition forces down costs and promotes allocative and technical (productive) efficiency.

Australia suffers more than most developed countries from the protectionist fallacy. People buy into the idea that local jobs are 'saved' by it. All protection can do is delay the inevitable and, usually, when the trade barriers are removed the domestic industry is so hopelessly inefficient it closes. Ask Ford, Holden and Toyota if you need proof of this.



Wednesday, 6 November 2013

Unemployment at 5.7%

Australia's latest unemployment figures released today show 5.7% of the workforce as unemployed. Depending on how you look at it that's up 0.1% or steady because last months figure was revised upwards to 5.7%.

The real worry is that jobs are not being created very quickly. There was a net rise of about 1000 jobs if you accept part-time jobs, which rose, to be as useful as full time jobs, which fell. Of course nobody does see them as equivalent so there was really a net fall in employment.

The participation rate also fell to 64.8%. While this is the lowest level since 2006 a quick look at the chart in the ABC News report shows that while there is a slight trend downwards this is not severe and may well indicate the relatively high level of unemployment and scarcity of full time jobs has put some job seekers off for now.

Australia considers 5% unemployment as 'full employment'. That's quite a high level to accept as full employment, but few OECD countries are achieving 5.7% let alone 5%. Use the link to the map below to see where Australia ranks (hover over a country to get the data).

Australia should be concerned about unemployment. Those unemployed suffer a lower standard of living and impose costs upon the economy and taxpayers. Rising unemployment also indicates slow growth and possibly skill shortages among the available workforce. If the upward trend in unemployment, which started in early 2012, continues it will require further policy measures to boost growth.




Friday, 30 August 2013

Measuring inflation and the standard of living

Australia has an odd way of measuring inflation compared to the rest of the world. The data is collected infrequently and only in the urban areas.

This makes the measure difficult to use when answering the question "Is the standard of living rising or falling for Australians?"

Of course the real cost of goods and services is only one way of measuring the standard of living, but it is an important one. And in the election campaign much has been made of 'skyrocketing prices" by the idiot Abbott and his cronies.

This article in the Guardian Australia shows that Australians are actually better off in real terms when considering their nominal incomes and the price level. This is very much in contrast to the rest of the developed world and you have to ask why Labor have not made much more of this. But that's another story.

What the article does show is how important it is to include the correct prices of goods in any calculation of inflation and how you have to compare it to incomes when considering real incomes. It also exposes the Liberals claims on the cost of living as a crude distortion of the facts. But we are used to that from Australian politicians aren't we?

Friday, 1 February 2013

The Standard of Living


VCE Economics really has one aim. To explain what influences the Standard of Living of Australians. All that you learn can be related to this.

Unfortunately it is not at all clear what 'standard of living' means and you will profit from gaining a good understanding of this early.

There are two ways of looking at the standard of living:

Material standards of living - judged by how many goods and services the population can consume

Non-material standard of living - which relates to the wider quality of life. For example living in the UK means coping with the awful weather month in month out, while the pleasures of Melbourne's climate, whatever you may think of it, means you have a better quality of life. Leisure time and the quality of activities, levels of pollution, stress levels and so on all contribute to non-material living standards.

But how can we measure Standard of Living? As non-material living standards are important GDP alone is not enough. Indeed GDP has many shortcomings and at the very least needs to be converted to Real disposable GDP per capita.

There have been several attempts to measure the standard of living, the Human Development Index is the best known, but Australia has made its own attempt with the Genuine Progress Indicator.





Email me at mark.russell43@hotmail.com for some notes in word format