Showing posts with label Material living standards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Material living standards. Show all posts

Monday, 11 April 2016

The cost of economic growth may be falling

In economics there are costs and benefits associated with every decision and every change. In recent years when considering the desirability of economic growth the costs have become somewhat more important than they were.

For generations economic growth was seen as good. The benefits of higher real incomes and a higher material standard of living were seen as the primary long-run goal of economic activity. It was not until the 1960's when E.J. Mishan wrote 'The Cost of Economic Growth' that economists began to seriously consider that there was a serious downside to continuous growth.

Today we understand that non-material living standards can be seriously affected by growth (take for example China's atmospheric pollution) often through negative externalities. Also we know that material living standards are are threatened by some elements of growth, such as global warming.

Some economists supported continued economic growth following Mishan's criticism, such as W. Beckerman in his 'In Defence of Economic Growth'. He argued that technical progress would allow society to overcome many of the problems of growth and that the higher real incomes obtained through growth would allow us to devote the necessary resources to deal with the problem.

There had been little to support Beckerman's contention until recently. The article from the New York Times described how growth and CO2 emissions have become 'decoupled' in some advanced economies. This holds out the possibility of economic growth without greater environmental damage. There is a long way to go however, only 21 out of 191 countries have achieved growth without more CO2.


This article is well suited to VCE students as they look at living standards and economic growth in Outcome 2 of Unit 3. It also provides IB students with the opportunity to look at the wider aspects of growth and to evaluate its impact. It provides all of us with the reminder that there are always costs and benefits to consider.

Friday, 1 April 2016

New minimum wage rates - good or bad for the British economy?

The UK today introduced a new 'National Living Wage' which is effectively a minimum wage. The UK already has a minimum wage, but that's 50p less an hour.

There is a great deal of support for this move, but also a great deal of opposition.

Those who support the 'Living Wage' argue that the present minimum wage is insufficient to provide workers and their families with a reasonable standard of living. This is where the term 'Living wage' comes from.

Those who oppose the move say that many workers will lose their jobs or be forced to accept shorter hours as employers cannot afford the higher wage rate. They suggest that the market won't support the employment levels currently enjoyed at the higher wage rate.

The economics of this can can complex, but the diagram below shows the most basic analysis.
 In the diagram above the free market wage rate is 0W* and 0N* hours of labour are hired by firms. Suppose that the National Living Wage (NLW) is introduced at 0WH. As this new NLW is above the market rate the effect on employment will be detrimental with hours of labour employed falling to 0Nd. Those who remain in work will, of course, be better off, but this is cold comfort for those who loose their jobs.

If the new NLW is imposed at 0WL then there is no effect on employment at all. Workers will continue to be paid the higher open market rate.

The BBC article below shows the situation is far from this simple. Here are a few considerations.

* There are people earning less than the new NLW. How could they be earning less than the free market rate (0W*) at present? Possibly because of an imbalance of power between employer and employee meaning the employer can exploit the weak position of such workers (perhaps in a non-unionised industry). In this case the employers are being forced to pay a fairer wage rate.

* If the new NLW is above the market rate how many workers might lose their jobs? This will depend on the elasticity of demand for labour and this in turn depends on the elasticity of demand for the product they produce (derived demand).

* Looking at the BBC article shows that different regions of the UK will see different proportions of the workforce affects receiving pay rises. The distribution of gains between regions will be very different therefore on real incomes and hours worked. Overall their may be an improvement in the equality of the distribution of income, this can be measured by the gini-coefficient.

* In the short run there may be job losses due to the higher NLW. In the long run the improved standard of living may result in high overall benefits to society (lower government spending, improved productivity etc.) 

There are many aspects of the introduction of the NLW to consider. Issues are rarely as simple as they first appear and further consideration often draws us to a different conclusion.


 This article is more likely to be useful to IB students than VCE. However VCE students can still look at it as an application of demand and supply analysis. For IB students the evaluation of a measure is very important and this needs to be based on analysis (explaining using theory). Ther are numerous ways the initial demand and supply analysis could be developed.