Showing posts with label recession. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recession. Show all posts

Tuesday, 21 March 2017

A trade off for monetary policy

Since the global financial crisis interest rates in the UK (and the US, Europe and Japan) have been at record lows. The aim was to boost Aggregate Demand and avoid prolonged recession and promote faster recovery. An interesting trade-off has been highlighted as a result of this policy.

The low interest rates have indeed maintained UK output, according to a Bank of England economist, but the low rates have meant firms that should have ceased operations have been able to survive. Around 1.5 million jobs have been protected according to Andrew Haldane.

Of course saving jobs was exactly what the Bank of England were trying to do when they lowered rates. The unintended consequence of this action was that it reduced the costs of poorly performing firms. Those who were not efficient enough to earn the profits necessary to repay loans at 'normal' rates of interest have been able to survive ('Zombie firms' according to Haldane).

The impact has been to allow low productivity jobs to survive and this has led to poor improvements in productivity overall, because the productivity figures reported are an average over the whole economy.

Productivity is a measure of efficiency. It records how many inputs are required to produce a given level of output. For economic growth to deliver higher standards of living a rise in productivity year on year is crucial. The UK has a very poor productivity record generally and the low interest rates since 2008 have allowed this to get worse.

Haldane says that he is happy to have seen 1.5 million jobs saved rather than 2% productivity growth. At least 1.5 million people and their families will be agreeing with him.


As this is an article about the UK as an example it is directly useful to IB students. However VCE students can see the example of how all policy has trade-offs and policy actions often have unintended consequences, such as supporting inefficiency to reduce unemployment.

Thursday, 22 December 2016

How economies are highly interdependent

I found the article below while looking through papers on newspapermap.com. It is about how Brazil's recession is affecting Argentina's economic growth. It also details how some other injections into the circular flow will help Argentine growth in 2017.

The key here is that exports are an injection into the circular flow, but depend on foreign income, not domestic income. Therefore as Brazil suffers its 'worse recession in 100 years' their major trading partner suffers a fall in Aggregate Demand too.

This article lends itself to AD/AS analysis and discussion of multipliers. It could be taken to be an article on international trade, but for me would be best suited to a macro IA that discusses how changes in injections have a multiplier effect and to discuss the impact on the economy, government, taxpayers etc.



Wednesday, 7 December 2016

Australia is not 'half way' to recession.

Yesterday it was revealed that in the September quarter the Australian economy shrank by 0.5%. Some commentators chose to say that Australia was 'half way to recession' on the basis of the semi-technical definition that a recession is two quarters of declining real GDP.

The fact that Australian GDP has fallen is remarkable and looking at the reasons for this is a very important exercise. There are many articles on the fall in. output that might make useful Macro IA's for the IB students.

The article below is from the Guardian Australia and as always has lots of data and opinion. The opinion makes it unsuitable for an IA article itself, but it can help you write a commentary.

What could be the causes of the fall in real GDP?
Falling AD?
AS not growing fast enough?

Certianly plenty to apply in this story to the AD/AS model.


See above - this is classic IA topic stuff. Causes, consequences and policy implications galore. For VCE students an absolute must to read as well.

Saturday, 15 October 2016

Monetary Policy ineffective?

As IB students move to looking at macroeconomic policy I will provide some articles that highlight some recent issues and also help give context to the importance of understanding the theory of policy is important to understanding its use in reality.

The article below makes lots of points. It talks about how the Australian Treasurer (Finance Minister) believes that Monetary Policy has become ineffective in boosting economic activity at present. It also talks about how Fiscal and Supply-side policy must work together to achieve macroeconomic goals.

I am going to concentrate on monetary policy here. Morrison asserts that further interest rate cuts (Australian interest rates have fallen from 4.75% to 1.5% since 2012) will do nothing to stimulate the economy. This is suggesting that the transmission mechanism by which lower rates stimulate economic activity and raise the price level has stopped working.

The theory, which you will learn, suggests that lowering interest rates will raise Consumer and Investment spending and probably Net Exports, all components of Aggregate Demand. However when interest rates are very low many believe that the incentives to change behaviour cease to be significant. If coupled with lower consumer and business confidence even negative interest rates cannot help stimulate the economy on their own.

This is very much a current policy debate. Similar arguments are being had in Japan and Europe where the central banks not only set negative rates but are printing money to try to stimulate the economy.

Notice Morrison's use to the phrase 'pushing on a piece of string' - a classic term used to describe how lowering interest rates does nothing to solve a recession. The answer is more government spending and infrastructure investment. Of course that policy will be cheaper to finance when interest rates are low - so maybe low rates still have a role.


Note that there is a lot of politics in this. Morrison, for example, refuses to acknowledge that more government spending is needed because the political priority is to cut spending to 'solve' the budget deficit. 

There are lots of articles on this argument - look for them for your IA.

Wednesday, 27 July 2016

Headline inflation down, underlying inflation up

Yesterday the June quarter inflation figures showed that the CPI in Australia was running at an annual rate of 1%. That is well below the RBA target of 2- 3% on average over the business cycle. There is a wide expectation of further interest rate cuts, if not at the August meeting of the RBA certainly by the end of the year.

The figures, which are summarized below by the ABS, do disguise a rise in underlying inflation (that is with volatile items removed) has risen to 1.5% (from 1.4%). Underlying inflation does give a better picture of what is happening in the economy, but is still very low. Indeed these are the lowest recorded inflation figures for 17 years.


The question of the next move in monetary policy is dominating the press. Many argue that the RBA must lower interest rates to boost Aggregate Demand to avoid deflation and possible recession. However others, such as former RBA Board member Professor Warwick McKibbin, argues that moving rates to near zero (or zero in Japan) did nothing to help other economies as changes in rates at such low level has no significant effect on saving and investment incentives. 

The danger of very low rates lies in reducing retirement incomes and further distorting the housing market.


The article is of direct relevance to VCE students who must be aware of Australian inflation movements, the influences on the figures and the monetary policy response. IB students will find this useful as an example of inflationary pressures and policy response, they should also look at the use of inflation targets and pros and cons of monetary policy in a situation of low inflation/rates where 'conventional monetary policy' is ineffective.

Friday, 22 July 2016

If you needed proof confidence is important, look no further than the UK

The decision of the UK to leave the European Union (EU) was widely predicted to be an economic disaster. Therefore we shouldn't be surprised that businesses and consumers have reacted to the move based on the uncertainty this situation has created.

A survey recently published survey shows there has been a sharp slowdown in orders, which will work through the economy to mean lower output. The slowdown is the worst since the Global Financial Crisis.

Both Consumption spending and Investment spending, both components of Aggregate Demand (AD) are partly determined by household and firms confidence (sentiment). Put simply if households are worried about future income they will spend less and save more now. Firms will not invest as much if they are uncertain about future prospects. Brexit has handed out one huge dollop of uncertainty and households and firms are reacting exactly as economic theory predicts.

The effect is to reduce both Consumer and Investment spending and AD will fall.
The diagram shows the result of a fall in business and consumer confidence. Inflationary pressure is reduced and this may well lead to the Bank of England having to cut interest rates and engage in more quantitative easing as the UK inflation rate is already well below target. Also with lower output UK economic growth will falter and the possibility of recession and higher unemployment will mean the government might have to allow the budget deficit to increase. 

The Bank of England has already indicated that they will take an accommodating stance  and the new British Chancellor (Treasury minister) has said the aim of returning the government budget to balance by 2020 will be abandoned. 


VCE students can use this to apply their knowledge of budgetary policy and note the link to monetary policy for the 'policy mix'. For IB students this is an excellent example of fiscal and monetary policy operation using the AD/AS model to analyze the consequences and responses. Not that there will be both discretionary and automatic responses from fiscal policy.

Wednesday, 27 April 2016

Australian inflation causes a degree of panic

There are interesting reactions to the latest inflation figures for Australia. The contribution to the Australian annual inflation rate for the last quarter (three months Jan to March) was -0.2%. In Australia this is being reported as 'deflation' and the stock market and Australian dollar both fell sharply.

As shown by the two articles below Australia is taking this news far more seriously than the rest of the world. The Guardian reports that CPI inflation has fallen to 1.3% per year, while the Australian uses the word deflation - i.e. just the change over the last three months.

Deflation is "the persistent fall in the average price level leading to a rise in the purchasing power of money" (Russell and Heathfield, Inflation and UK Monetary Policy 3/E). Clearly Australia has some way to go before it achieves deflation then. However the fear that the economy isn't doing as well as everybody thought and might be headed for recession is capturing the popular imagination.

As the data below shows there were particular classes of goods where prices fell, while other classes exhibited increases. On balance the general price level fell.

It will have to be the subject of another post to discuss the effects of deflation. The important point to note for now i that this weak inflation figure, well below the RBA target, and possibly indicating that inflation will fall further, means the RBA really should cut interest rates further. Given the time lags involved in the effect of monetary policy that means next Tuesday should see a rate cut.




The above shows how groups of goods in the CPI changed over the last three months

The Australian annual inflation rate over the last four years and the quarterly change is shown at the bottom. A falling general price level is highly unusual and may indicate a great deal of spare capacity in the economy.

This article is essential to VCE students who will need to be able to explain influences on both inflation and monetary policy.



Thursday, 3 March 2016

Growth in Australian economy 'not that bad'

Everyone knows that the mining boom is over. The non-mining sector is doing its best to save the economy from recession, but who actually gave it much hope?

Recent figures show that the Australian economy is growing much faster than we thought and 3% for 2015 isn't unreasonable. Of course this is at the lower end of Australia's growth target, but given the collapse of commodity prices and the decline in mining investment it is a nice surprise.

The Guardian have provided another excellent survey of economic data in the article linked below.

Notice that net exports are now a significant contributor to Australian growth. This is not from mining, but the non-mining sector. The depreciation of the Australian dollar has helped competitiveness and we are now seeing the 'J-curve' effect and confirmation that the Marshall-Lerner conditions apply.

Of course consumer spending (the largest contributor to GDP) and housing continue to be important. Should consumer sentiment drop there is still a danger of recession.

A good look through the data is advisable to all students, and you can play with the interactive graphs.


This article is essential reading for VCE Economics students. Understanding the influences on the Australian economy over the last four years (demand and supply side) is critical. For IB this article shows how a depreciation in the exchange rate has worked through to higher net exports as well as providing important examples for both Paper 1 and 2.

Saturday, 30 January 2016

Japan's negative interest rates

Monetary policy is a key tool of economic management. It is usually applied by Central Banks to control inflation. The main tool of monetary policy is the rate of interest, although since 2008 the creation of additional money to add to the money supply (known as quantitative easing) has become common.

When interest rates are changed they affect the decisions of firms and households so that consumption and investment may change. Interest rate movements can also affect exchange rates. Therefore the policy can influence Aggregate Demand (AD).

The Japanese economy has seen many years of slow growth or recession. The chart below shows that Japan's relatively poor economic performance dates back to the 1990's, but the GFC has affected them like every other major economy.

The Japanese government has used expansionary fiscal (budgetary) policy and expansionary monetary policy since the 1990's. This has had little success in stimulating the Japanese economy.

The latest move has been to set negative interest rates. This applies to commercial bank deposits with the Bank of Japan. It means it costs the commercial banks money to have cash in their accounts at the Bank of Japan. Therefore, reason the Bank of Japan, it is more profitable for the commercial banks to lend the money to their customers and so stimulate AD.

Will it work? That seems unlikely given the failure of earlier stimulus measures which include a large quantity of money creation. However the fact that the Bank has tried to do something extra has encouraged the stock market.


Questions.

1. Note the fall in the value of the Yen described in the article. Can you explain why the Yen depreciated?
2. What factors might cause an expansionary monetary policy be ineffective in raising AD?

This article has great relevance to IB students study of macroeconomic policy and exchange rates. For VCE the process of how monetary policy works and its influence on AD through consumption, investment and net exports, via exchange rates, is equally relevant.