The European Central Bank has been fighting the danger of deflation in the Euro Area. Deflation is a sustained fall in the general price level so that the purchasing power of money rises.
The purchasing power of money rising sounds good! However it is generally caused by low demand and so low growth, or even falling output. The most recent period of prolonged deflation occured during the Great Depression, and nobody wants to go back to that. When prices are falling consumers will wait to buy good and services as they expect them to become cheaper. The result is a downward spiral of prices and output.
The ECB has been using conventional expansionary monetary policy, interest rates are now 0%, and unconventional monetary policy, they are printing Euros through Quantitative Easing, in order to boost Aggregate Demand (AD) and so economic growth.
The report below suggests that this is now having some effect, but it is far from certain that a sustained upswing in output, wages and prices has yet been achieved, so they will continue the policy. (Note the difference in headline and core inflation which indicates that there is still some way to go before there is a sustained recovery.)
Showing posts with label Quantitative easing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Quantitative easing. Show all posts
Thursday, 9 March 2017
Thursday, 8 December 2016
Monetary policy in the EU
Here is another possible IA topic. The European Central Bank (ECB) is to extend its Quantitative Easing (QE) programme by nine months, but won't buy as many bonds each month.
You will recall that QE is like printing money to expand the money supply. The ECB buys bonds from the public adding to their cash holdings. This increases liquidity in the market and forces down yields on all financial assets. The hope is that this encourages households and firms to spend money (boost AD).
The question is, will it work? The phrase 'pushing on a piece of string' is often used to suggest that under current circumstances it will have little effect. But can it do any harm?
Notice that the Euro depreciated. This may help make Euro Area exports become more competitive if that situation persists.
You will recall that QE is like printing money to expand the money supply. The ECB buys bonds from the public adding to their cash holdings. This increases liquidity in the market and forces down yields on all financial assets. The hope is that this encourages households and firms to spend money (boost AD).
The question is, will it work? The phrase 'pushing on a piece of string' is often used to suggest that under current circumstances it will have little effect. But can it do any harm?
Notice that the Euro depreciated. This may help make Euro Area exports become more competitive if that situation persists.
This story is about monetary policy, but 'unconventional monetary policy'. It is a good topic for an IA. Again you may want to find other sources where the article leaves you more to say.
Labels:
Aggregate demand,
Bonds,
depreciation,
Exports,
Liquidity,
Monetary Policy,
Money supply,
Quantitative easing
Sunday, 25 September 2016
Sensible words
Gordon Brown as the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer (Treasurer or Finance Minister) had a 'Golden Rule'. Balance the budget of current expenditure over the economic cycle. That is he, like all sensible governments, separate the current and capital components of the government budget.
The article below says 'maybe this is a good idea?' Well while it is rather late this is a welcome contribution to the public debate.
It is not bad to borrow to invest!
The article below says 'maybe this is a good idea?' Well while it is rather late this is a welcome contribution to the public debate.
It is not bad to borrow to invest!
Labels:
Budgetary Policy,
Capital spending,
Current spending,
Fiscal Policy,
Monetary Policy,
Quantitative easing
Friday, 22 July 2016
If you needed proof confidence is important, look no further than the UK
The decision of the UK to leave the European Union (EU) was widely predicted to be an economic disaster. Therefore we shouldn't be surprised that businesses and consumers have reacted to the move based on the uncertainty this situation has created.
A survey recently published survey shows there has been a sharp slowdown in orders, which will work through the economy to mean lower output. The slowdown is the worst since the Global Financial Crisis.
Both Consumption spending and Investment spending, both components of Aggregate Demand (AD) are partly determined by household and firms confidence (sentiment). Put simply if households are worried about future income they will spend less and save more now. Firms will not invest as much if they are uncertain about future prospects. Brexit has handed out one huge dollop of uncertainty and households and firms are reacting exactly as economic theory predicts.
The effect is to reduce both Consumer and Investment spending and AD will fall.
A survey recently published survey shows there has been a sharp slowdown in orders, which will work through the economy to mean lower output. The slowdown is the worst since the Global Financial Crisis.
Both Consumption spending and Investment spending, both components of Aggregate Demand (AD) are partly determined by household and firms confidence (sentiment). Put simply if households are worried about future income they will spend less and save more now. Firms will not invest as much if they are uncertain about future prospects. Brexit has handed out one huge dollop of uncertainty and households and firms are reacting exactly as economic theory predicts.
The effect is to reduce both Consumer and Investment spending and AD will fall.
The diagram shows the result of a fall in business and consumer confidence. Inflationary pressure is reduced and this may well lead to the Bank of England having to cut interest rates and engage in more quantitative easing as the UK inflation rate is already well below target. Also with lower output UK economic growth will falter and the possibility of recession and higher unemployment will mean the government might have to allow the budget deficit to increase.
The Bank of England has already indicated that they will take an accommodating stance and the new British Chancellor (Treasury minister) has said the aim of returning the government budget to balance by 2020 will be abandoned.
VCE students can use this to apply their knowledge of budgetary policy and note the link to monetary policy for the 'policy mix'. For IB students this is an excellent example of fiscal and monetary policy operation using the AD/AS model to analyze the consequences and responses. Not that there will be both discretionary and automatic responses from fiscal policy.
Labels:
Aggregate demand,
Brexit,
budget deficit,
Business confidence,
Consumer Confidence,
Consumption,
Fiscal Policy,
Inflation,
Interest rates,
Investment,
Monetary Policy,
Quantitative easing,
recession,
uncertainty
Tuesday, 19 April 2016
"Monetary policy is not enough."
The Governor of the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has told a New York conference that monetary policy is not enough to allow faster growth. he suspects that the world has entered a period of much lower 'trend growth'.
Stevens has made a number of points and this is a quick summary of what I think he means:
1. With nine years of low interest rates there is no longer any room to boost Aggregate Demand (AD) with lower rates.
2. Simply 'printing money' ('Quantitative easing' or 'helicopter money) will also be ineffective.
Low confidence among both consumers and firms contribute to these first two points, but simply that the incentive provided by these measures is now too small. He therefore thinks the use of negative interest rates (as in Japan and the EU) will fail to raise economic growth.
3. More than monetary policy is needed to promote growth and that should be provided by increased government infrastructure spending.
He makes the point that this can be funded very cheaply by issuing bonds (government debt) at record low interest rates and that the return on this investment will far exceed the borrowing cost.
Stevens is not calling for a naive Keynesian fiscal boost. However he is calling for an end to 'austerity' and a blind adherence to the idea that any government Budget deficit is bad. (Some are, some are not.) What Stevens is calling for are projects that will assist the private sector to grow through active supply side policies which have the advantage of adding to AD as well.
Finally Stevens talks about the wider implications of monetary policy. He pointed out that the low interest rates are destroying retirement plans. Pension (superannuation) funds rely on investing in safe assets such as bonds. The interest rates earned on these assets are so low many find their retirement plans are being ruined. A short period of low interest rates will not affect pensions too badly, they can catch up, but we are now nearly a decade into low rates and that has serious implications.
Stevens has made a number of points and this is a quick summary of what I think he means:
1. With nine years of low interest rates there is no longer any room to boost Aggregate Demand (AD) with lower rates.
2. Simply 'printing money' ('Quantitative easing' or 'helicopter money) will also be ineffective.
Low confidence among both consumers and firms contribute to these first two points, but simply that the incentive provided by these measures is now too small. He therefore thinks the use of negative interest rates (as in Japan and the EU) will fail to raise economic growth.
3. More than monetary policy is needed to promote growth and that should be provided by increased government infrastructure spending.
He makes the point that this can be funded very cheaply by issuing bonds (government debt) at record low interest rates and that the return on this investment will far exceed the borrowing cost.
Stevens is not calling for a naive Keynesian fiscal boost. However he is calling for an end to 'austerity' and a blind adherence to the idea that any government Budget deficit is bad. (Some are, some are not.) What Stevens is calling for are projects that will assist the private sector to grow through active supply side policies which have the advantage of adding to AD as well.
Finally Stevens talks about the wider implications of monetary policy. He pointed out that the low interest rates are destroying retirement plans. Pension (superannuation) funds rely on investing in safe assets such as bonds. The interest rates earned on these assets are so low many find their retirement plans are being ruined. A short period of low interest rates will not affect pensions too badly, they can catch up, but we are now nearly a decade into low rates and that has serious implications.
This article is applicable to VCE and IB students. Australia has record low interest rates and the 'policy mix' between monetary and budgetary policy in Australia is a crucially important area of study. For IB students the limitations of monetary policy and the interaction between fiscal and monetary policy and the operation of supply side policy in the policy mix is directly relevant to Paper 1.
Labels:
Aggregate demand,
Austerity,
budget deficit,
Business confidence,
Consumer Confidence,
Economic growth,
Infrastructure,
Monetary Policy,
Quantitative easing,
Supply-side policy,
Trend growth
Saturday, 30 January 2016
Japan's negative interest rates
Monetary policy is a key tool of economic management. It is usually applied by Central Banks to control inflation. The main tool of monetary policy is the rate of interest, although since 2008 the creation of additional money to add to the money supply (known as quantitative easing) has become common.
When interest rates are changed they affect the decisions of firms and households so that consumption and investment may change. Interest rate movements can also affect exchange rates. Therefore the policy can influence Aggregate Demand (AD).
The Japanese economy has seen many years of slow growth or recession. The chart below shows that Japan's relatively poor economic performance dates back to the 1990's, but the GFC has affected them like every other major economy.
The Japanese government has used expansionary fiscal (budgetary) policy and expansionary monetary policy since the 1990's. This has had little success in stimulating the Japanese economy.
The latest move has been to set negative interest rates. This applies to commercial bank deposits with the Bank of Japan. It means it costs the commercial banks money to have cash in their accounts at the Bank of Japan. Therefore, reason the Bank of Japan, it is more profitable for the commercial banks to lend the money to their customers and so stimulate AD.
Will it work? That seems unlikely given the failure of earlier stimulus measures which include a large quantity of money creation. However the fact that the Bank has tried to do something extra has encouraged the stock market.
Questions.
1. Note the fall in the value of the Yen described in the article. Can you explain why the Yen depreciated?
2. What factors might cause an expansionary monetary policy be ineffective in raising AD?
This article has great relevance to IB students study of macroeconomic policy and exchange rates. For VCE the process of how monetary policy works and its influence on AD through consumption, investment and net exports, via exchange rates, is equally relevant.
When interest rates are changed they affect the decisions of firms and households so that consumption and investment may change. Interest rate movements can also affect exchange rates. Therefore the policy can influence Aggregate Demand (AD).
The Japanese economy has seen many years of slow growth or recession. The chart below shows that Japan's relatively poor economic performance dates back to the 1990's, but the GFC has affected them like every other major economy.
The Japanese government has used expansionary fiscal (budgetary) policy and expansionary monetary policy since the 1990's. This has had little success in stimulating the Japanese economy.
The latest move has been to set negative interest rates. This applies to commercial bank deposits with the Bank of Japan. It means it costs the commercial banks money to have cash in their accounts at the Bank of Japan. Therefore, reason the Bank of Japan, it is more profitable for the commercial banks to lend the money to their customers and so stimulate AD.
Will it work? That seems unlikely given the failure of earlier stimulus measures which include a large quantity of money creation. However the fact that the Bank has tried to do something extra has encouraged the stock market.
Questions.
1. Note the fall in the value of the Yen described in the article. Can you explain why the Yen depreciated?
2. What factors might cause an expansionary monetary policy be ineffective in raising AD?
This article has great relevance to IB students study of macroeconomic policy and exchange rates. For VCE the process of how monetary policy works and its influence on AD through consumption, investment and net exports, via exchange rates, is equally relevant.
Labels:
Aggregate demand,
exchange rates,
Inflation,
Interest rates,
Monetary Policy,
Quantitative easing,
recession
Thursday, 22 January 2015
Quantatative Easing in Europe
Australian monetary policy remains 'conventional'. The RBA adjusts the cash rate to influence interest rates throughout the economy. Those changes (although there have been none since 2013) work through the various monetary transmission mechanisms to affect Aggregate Demand (AD) and so inflation.
However when AD is very low and economic growth is really weak there is a limit to the amount conventional monetary policy can do. This occurs where interest rates approach zero. There are no more interest rate cuts possible to boost consumption and investment spending.
In the Eurozone the European Central Bank has set a cash rate of 0.05%. While some countries have set small negative rates (Switzerland for example) it is thought that changes at the rate at this level makes little difference to economic behaviour (Keynes talked of a liquidity trap at low interest rates which might be applicable here).
So the solution adopted in the US, the UK and Japan has been to print money to boost economic activity. This is called Quantitative Easing. The money is used to buy 'bonds' and this drives the price of those bonds up, meaning that they pay holders a lower real rate of interest. This helps by making borrowing cheaper in the economy and also boosting the money supply.
While some might worry about inflation when money is printed in this way they are missing the point. The aim is to inflate the economy, boosting AD and raising the level of economic activity leading to higher GDP and employment. The Eurozone badly needs this stimulus, as do all the countries that trade with Europe.
The BBC page explains the plan and how QE works. Why is this important for VCE? The same monetary transmission mechanisms work in Australia as work in Europe. It is essential you understand them for Unit 4.
However when AD is very low and economic growth is really weak there is a limit to the amount conventional monetary policy can do. This occurs where interest rates approach zero. There are no more interest rate cuts possible to boost consumption and investment spending.
In the Eurozone the European Central Bank has set a cash rate of 0.05%. While some countries have set small negative rates (Switzerland for example) it is thought that changes at the rate at this level makes little difference to economic behaviour (Keynes talked of a liquidity trap at low interest rates which might be applicable here).
So the solution adopted in the US, the UK and Japan has been to print money to boost economic activity. This is called Quantitative Easing. The money is used to buy 'bonds' and this drives the price of those bonds up, meaning that they pay holders a lower real rate of interest. This helps by making borrowing cheaper in the economy and also boosting the money supply.
While some might worry about inflation when money is printed in this way they are missing the point. The aim is to inflate the economy, boosting AD and raising the level of economic activity leading to higher GDP and employment. The Eurozone badly needs this stimulus, as do all the countries that trade with Europe.
The BBC page explains the plan and how QE works. Why is this important for VCE? The same monetary transmission mechanisms work in Australia as work in Europe. It is essential you understand them for Unit 4.
Labels:
Aggregate demand,
Cash rate,
Consumption,
Economic growth,
Employment,
Inflation,
Interest rates,
Investment,
Liquidity Trap,
Monetary Policy,
monetary transmission mechanism,
Money supply,
Quantitative easing
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
