Showing posts with label Subsidies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Subsidies. Show all posts

Monday, 6 March 2017

Carbon emissions do respond to policy

In Australia it is common to come across both climate change deniers and those who deny that policy measures to reduce global warming will be effective. Often the claim is made that the policy measures do too much harm to people's livelihood's now to be worth the benefits later (dingos kidneys obviously).

The story below from the BBC reports on a record fall in UK coal use and as a result carbon emissions. It is a story that suggests when policy is properly applied it can have a significant impact.

In the case of the UK (and here you can read a combination of EU and UK policy) thare are a raft of complementary policies that have driven lower emissions.

Briefly the UK policy includes:

  • Setting a carbon budget - a proposed limit to carbon emissions that falls over time
  • Taxing carbon emissions, including a minimum tax on carbon.
  • Subsidizing renewable energy.
  • Promoting and funding a shift away from coal to cleaner fuels (move to low-carbon technologies)
  • Funding public information of the dangers of global warming and ways to reduce carbon emissions.
  • Subsidizing home improvements and strict regulation on new building standards e.g. insulation standards such as compulsory double glazing.
The message here is that one policy alone is not really that effective, but a combination of policies that raise the price and shift the demand curve to the left do have a significant effect.

One point to note is that serious attempts in UK policy on this issue began in 1990. While policy has intensified since 2006 there has been a fairly sudden change recently, as the article notes. Initially policy met an inelastic response to price changes and only minor changes that could be said to have moved the demand curve left. 

Now the policy has reached the 'tipping point'. We are observing an elastic response to price (see article) and behaviour has been changed. Economists knew this point would be reached, but predicting how much pressure needed to be applied to reach it was never clear.

David Pearce, you were right. I'm sorry you never lived to see it.


Monday, 3 October 2016

Road pricing in Melbourne - excellent idea

Infrastructure Victoria today issued a 200+ page interim report on future transport infrastructure planning in Melbourne. There is much in it that makes sense, including a cost-benefit analysis report showing which projects will yield more benefits than costs.

One of their proposals (and it is only an option) is to charge motorists $5 to enter the CBD. The aim is to reduce congestion by making people time their journeys differently and to move others on to public transport. The report suggests that 20% of journeys taking between 7am and 9am could be moved to other times.

This proposal is founded on the experience of many other cities. London, Singapore and Stockholm all have well developed charging schemes, although they are not all the same. London charges one amount between 7am and 6pm while Singapore varies the charge according to the time of day and level of congestion.

Road pricing schemes are highly effective when combined with other measures, such as improved public transport and subsidies of that system, park and ride schemes, car sharing schemes and high car parking charges for example. Without additional measures the price elasticity of demand is too inelastic for road pricing to make a significant difference, due to the essential nature of transport generally and the sheer convenience of driving your own vehicle.

Both major parties in Victoria rejected the proposed charges on the morning the report was published. So much for well considered long-term policy making. I have sent a letter!


This article has some relevance to VCE as it deals with market failure (the negative externalities of using a car and congesting a road) and the price mechanism. IB students are much better equipped to investigate this topic using their knowledge of market failure and policy. (Good EE topic?)

Wednesday, 12 February 2014

Closure of Toyota raises many (old) issues

The closure of Toyota should come as no surprise. Australia is not a place where anyone can make standard cars competitively.

There are three areas to be interested in this story, which is a VERY LIKELY candidate for the exam in November.

* Why Australia is an expensive place to make cars

* Whether governments should provide assistance to declining or uncompetitive industries

* The winners and losers from putting a tax on imports

There are so many issues here that I can't attempt to talk about them in one post, but I will return to each in the future and expand upon each heading.

For now lets think about why the car makers say it costs them four times as much to make a car in Australia than in Asia and twice as much as in Europe.

One issue is the Minimum Efficient Scale of production. The Economies of Scale of car making mean that as the size of a plant increases the long-run average cost of production falls. But unlike the 'text-book' examples Diseconomies of Scale never occur meaning that there is a point at which every additional unit of production costs the same. This is shown in the diagram below.


For the Australian car makers the scale of production never reaches the quantity MES, (Minimum Efficient Scale) indeed it is probably at best 40% of that quantity.

Although there are other factors to consider, such as comparatively low productivity and high wages in Australia, the small scale of production is  major reason why the car making industry was always doomed.

The Guardian has an excellent article which connects most of the relevant issues.


Monday, 1 April 2013

Massive Holden subsidies harm consumers

It was revealed that Holden had received over $2billion in subsidies in the last 12 years, far more than previously thought.

The Australian government has long argued that subsidising industries is good for jobs in Australia. But most economists would disagree with this as both shortsighted and damaging to the economy.

The argument for subsidy relies on the idea that if it was absent then all the jobs in the industry would be lost, leading to higher unemployment and a lower standard of living in Australia.

The argument against this was first put forward by Adam Smith a then David Ricardo and has been backed up by a further 200 years of economics research. Simon Cowan of The Centre for Independent Studies has argued that if the subsidies were removed then consumers would benefit from lower car prices and the standard of living would rise as resources were redeployed to efficient industries instead.

The argument works like this:

* The car industry in Australia is uncompetitive and inefficient.

* Removing the subsidy means the industry loses money and shuts down.

* Those currently employed in car manufacturing and its supporting industries move to other sectors.

* The resources currently used up by the car industry are released for use by efficient Australian industries.

* All cars sold in Australia are imported from abroad (up from 75%) - these cost less to produce and will become cheaper as firstly the import taxes needed to protect Australian producers are scrapped and foreign producers gain economies of scale.

* Therefore consumers gain by getting their cars more cheaply (approx 1.1 million new cars are sold each year)

* Government can use the money used for subsidies to help reduce taxes or pay for other programmes such as Gonski.

Smith pointed out that competition leads to productive efficiency. Smith and Ricardo showed that with free international trade the most efficient suppliers produce the goods people want with each country specialising in the sectors they are comparatively best at. AS A RESULT EVERYONE IS BETTER OFF.

Australia has never been keen on this argument and despite reforms going back to Hawke/Keating Australia remains the most protectionist country in the G20.