Adam Smith and David Ricardo gave economics the theory of International Trade by 1817 (Smith 1776) and what they said remains the basis of the reason economists favour free trade over protection.
The theory says that countries should specialise according to their comparative advantage and as a result overall production will rise and these gains in output will be redistributed through trade (i.e. swapping of goods and services).
To achieve specialisation a country must grow some industries while others shrink (those in which other countries specialise). The result will be more jobs in some industries and less in others.
The loss of jobs is regrettable and is referred to as an 'adjustment cost.' Economists are fully aware of this cost and could explain to those who are now unemployed the overall benefit of the process. It will not be a popular message with the unemployed.
The World Bank is reported to have written a report confirming Smith and Ricardo's conclusions. The growth of free trade (Globalization) has led to overall more jobs, but some have lost out. They estimate 20% of job losses in some areas, like the USA, are due to free trade.
The problem is that there is no guarantee that a country will gain as many jobs through their specialization as they lose. Portugal is a good example. They have lost many jobs to lower cost manufacturing nations (such as Eastern Europe and China), but don't have the comparative advantage in high tech and knowledge based industries they need to replace those jobs.
So the World Bank report is basically saying Smith and Ricardo were right.
Showing posts with label International Trade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label International Trade. Show all posts
Thursday, 6 October 2016
Tuesday, 26 July 2016
Despite everything we know Australia can't shake protectionist instincts
Australia was built on the foundation of protectionism. In the early years of the colony and Federation large tariffs were placed on imports and Australian producers thrived. The practice continued until the 1980's without serious challenge.
The result of Australian protection was exactly as economic theory predicted. Short-term advantage and long-term harm. By the 1980's Australia was uncompetitive, produced low quality goods and vested interest groups from industry and trade unions demanded more not less protection.
Great progress was made after the Hawke government began to dismantle barriers and the benefits were seen in lower prices and greater variety for consumers. Australian industry competed or died. Short-term pain, but long-term gain.
It is particularly disappointing then that politicians revert to protection whenever it is easier to do so than dealing with the root cause of uncompetitiveness. We saw it when the carbon-tax was repealed in the 'why should we suffer' argument that let the rest of the world disadvantage itself by doing the right thing. Now we see it with steel and shipbuilding.
The Productivity Commission has described the insistence on building the new Australian submarines in Australia using Australian steel as adding 30% to the costs of the project. The only justification is to keep jobs in Australia. They point out that this isn't the only areas that are getting regular, although often disguised, protection, with agriculture particularly benefiting.
The people paying the extra $15bn cost of the submarines are the taxpayer, (so much for reducing the deficit too), generally the consumer pays the extra price.
The result of Australian protection was exactly as economic theory predicted. Short-term advantage and long-term harm. By the 1980's Australia was uncompetitive, produced low quality goods and vested interest groups from industry and trade unions demanded more not less protection.
Great progress was made after the Hawke government began to dismantle barriers and the benefits were seen in lower prices and greater variety for consumers. Australian industry competed or died. Short-term pain, but long-term gain.
It is particularly disappointing then that politicians revert to protection whenever it is easier to do so than dealing with the root cause of uncompetitiveness. We saw it when the carbon-tax was repealed in the 'why should we suffer' argument that let the rest of the world disadvantage itself by doing the right thing. Now we see it with steel and shipbuilding.
The Productivity Commission has described the insistence on building the new Australian submarines in Australia using Australian steel as adding 30% to the costs of the project. The only justification is to keep jobs in Australia. They point out that this isn't the only areas that are getting regular, although often disguised, protection, with agriculture particularly benefiting.
The people paying the extra $15bn cost of the submarines are the taxpayer, (so much for reducing the deficit too), generally the consumer pays the extra price.
This article is useful for VCE students as it represents examples of current trade and supply side policy. It also represents a significant charge on government expenditure and so influences the Budget. IB students will be able to use this as an example of (shameless) protectionism and an illustration of the pros and cons of undertaking such a policy.
Labels:
IB Paper 2,
Imports,
International Trade,
Non-tariff barriers,
Protection,
Tariffs,
VCE Unit 3 and 4
Monday, 27 June 2016
After Brexit what next for Britain's trade
After the (disastrous) result of the UK's vote to exit from the EU a good question is what trade arrangements can be made for the future.
The EU operates a 'single market'. There are no restrictions on the movement of goods, services, people or money. This is a completely 'free trade area' and the countries that operate with the Euro as their currency also eliminate any exchange rate transaction costs.
The UK sends about half it's exports of goods to the EU. The services sector is the crucial one however, with the City of London (the financial sector) easily the most important single part of the UK economy.
The UK now finds itself back at the basic level of trying to negotiate trade deals with the EU and replace all the trade deals that cease to exist with the rest of the world when leaving the EU.
There are a hierarchy of arrangements, from simple bilateral 'concession deals' with individual countries, to Free Trade Areas (which cover goods not services) right up to full access to the EU's single market (but at a cost).
The BBC sets out five alternative new models for the UK/EU trading relationship. It is rare to have the chance to pick where on the ladder of trade agreements you will sit. The pro's and cons of each arrangement need to be carefully considered.
What is clear is that none of the five options the BBC outline will prove acceptable to those who voted 'Leave' in the British referendum and simultaneously protect the UK's vital services sector. I hate to say 'I told you so', Brexiters.
The EU operates a 'single market'. There are no restrictions on the movement of goods, services, people or money. This is a completely 'free trade area' and the countries that operate with the Euro as their currency also eliminate any exchange rate transaction costs.
The UK sends about half it's exports of goods to the EU. The services sector is the crucial one however, with the City of London (the financial sector) easily the most important single part of the UK economy.
The UK now finds itself back at the basic level of trying to negotiate trade deals with the EU and replace all the trade deals that cease to exist with the rest of the world when leaving the EU.
There are a hierarchy of arrangements, from simple bilateral 'concession deals' with individual countries, to Free Trade Areas (which cover goods not services) right up to full access to the EU's single market (but at a cost).
The BBC sets out five alternative new models for the UK/EU trading relationship. It is rare to have the chance to pick where on the ladder of trade agreements you will sit. The pro's and cons of each arrangement need to be carefully considered.
What is clear is that none of the five options the BBC outline will prove acceptable to those who voted 'Leave' in the British referendum and simultaneously protect the UK's vital services sector. I hate to say 'I told you so', Brexiters.
This article has relevance to both IB and VCE. VCE students can apply it to the deals made by Australia in recent years and the TPP proposal to look at their pros and cons. For IB the article is essential reading, partly for the theory and application, but mainly because this is exactly the sort of thing you would set questions about in Paper 2!
Labels:
Brexit,
Customs Union,
EEA,
EU,
exchange rate,
Free trade areas,
International Trade,
Single Market
Thursday, 11 February 2016
Anti-dumping measures, another crude attempt to resist efficiency?
Australia has decided to put an import tax (a tariff) on Italian canned tomatoes. Their argument that the Italians are pricing their product unfairly.
The one producer of canned tomatoes in Australia, SPC Ardmona, owned by Coca-cola Amatil, claim the Italian tomatoes are being 'dumped' on the Australian market.
The test Australia has applied is that Italian producers sell their product for less in Australia than they do at home. While this definition is seen a lot dumping is actually selling a good at less than the cost of production. Dumping is legal under World Trade Organization rules unless the foreign country can reliably show the negative effects of the exporting firm on the domestic producers.
It seems very unlikely that the Italians are making a loss. Italy's economy is in a perilous state and taking a long term loss just isn't an option.
The one producer of canned tomatoes in Australia, SPC Ardmona, owned by Coca-cola Amatil, claim the Italian tomatoes are being 'dumped' on the Australian market.
The test Australia has applied is that Italian producers sell their product for less in Australia than they do at home. While this definition is seen a lot dumping is actually selling a good at less than the cost of production. Dumping is legal under World Trade Organization rules unless the foreign country can reliably show the negative effects of the exporting firm on the domestic producers.
It seems very unlikely that the Italians are making a loss. Italy's economy is in a perilous state and taking a long term loss just isn't an option.
So what might be the motive? A clue might come from one of the supporters of the move, 'The Australian Campaign'. This group argue that we should all buy Australian products in order to keep jobs in Australia. Never mind the quality or price.
In the short term such a strategy may work. However in the long run this policy would allow inefficient and uncompetitive firms to survive. Consumers will be much worse off as they pay higher prices and exports would dwindle as firms, protected from competition, could lose world market share.
It is much better for jobs and prosperity to buy the most competitive goods, force domestic firms to compete or die and so allocate resources efficiently. It is very sad that protectionism continues to be given any credibility by such 'anti-dumping' actions,
In fact most anti-dumping tariffs last less than two years. They are withdrawn before the WTO can rule them as bogus.
The effect of the measure will raise profits and sales at SPC. The diagram shows this.
At present tomatoes sell for 60c a can. Total sales are 0Q2 with Q2 - Q1 being imported. Australian firms only produce 0Q1.
After the tariff the price rises to $1.40 a can and sales fall to 0Q4. Imports fall and domestic output rises to 0Q3.
The problem is that the consumers lose out.The whole coloured area is lost consumer surplus. The green area represents inefficient production costs and the red area consumer surplus transferred to domestic producers (SPC).
This article is directly relevant to VCE Unit 4 on policy goals and example of trade policy. IB students will study this is Unit 3 on international trade. The diagram shows how to apply theory to a real life example.
Update: Rather good article here,published on 16th Feb.
The Drum article is here
Update: Rather good article here,published on 16th Feb.
The Drum article is here
Labels:
Allocative efficiency,
Dumping,
International Trade,
Productive efficiency,
Protection,
Tariffs,
WTO
Wednesday, 27 January 2016
Will tax deal end transfer pricing?
Today many firms are multinationals and operate around the world. This has brought many benefits and the effect of globalization on living standards has been considerable. (This is actually the continuation of specialisation and trade you learn about in the first weeks of any economics course).
One of the drawbacks of this globalisation has been that multinationals have developed ways to pay their tax in countries where the profit taxes (corporate taxes) are lowest. This is, of course, rational behaviour for after-tax profit maximizing firms.
Transfer pricing works like this. Say you are a publisher and sell a really excellent economics textbook in the UK. The profit tax in the UK is 30%. Schools in Malaysia want to buy the book. Rather than sell them the book from the UK at £33 the publisher sells the books to their subsidiary in Singapore for £6, just over the cost of production. The subsidiary then sells the books to the Malaysian schools making all the profit in Singapore where the profit tax rate is just 10%.
I'm not bitter, but that's what Simon and Schuster did with my textbook, paying royalties only on the £6 earned in the UK.
This is perfectly legal. Firms such as Starbucks have bought their coffee from their Swiss subsidiary for the whole of Europe at high prices so the profit is declared in low tax Switzerland. Google have paid just £130m tax in ten years in the UK.
Now the OECD (The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development - the 'rich countries club') have signed a deal to make multinational firms pay tax where they really earn it. This means they should pay profit tax on all the operations in the country where their activities take place.
It will be difficult to police, and only 31 countries have signed. This means firms might just start declaring their profits in a country which has not signed. However the system they hope to implement should allow countries to demand tax on the amount of tax the firm would have made if declared correctly.
One of the drawbacks of this globalisation has been that multinationals have developed ways to pay their tax in countries where the profit taxes (corporate taxes) are lowest. This is, of course, rational behaviour for after-tax profit maximizing firms.
Transfer pricing works like this. Say you are a publisher and sell a really excellent economics textbook in the UK. The profit tax in the UK is 30%. Schools in Malaysia want to buy the book. Rather than sell them the book from the UK at £33 the publisher sells the books to their subsidiary in Singapore for £6, just over the cost of production. The subsidiary then sells the books to the Malaysian schools making all the profit in Singapore where the profit tax rate is just 10%.
I'm not bitter, but that's what Simon and Schuster did with my textbook, paying royalties only on the £6 earned in the UK.
This is perfectly legal. Firms such as Starbucks have bought their coffee from their Swiss subsidiary for the whole of Europe at high prices so the profit is declared in low tax Switzerland. Google have paid just £130m tax in ten years in the UK.
Now the OECD (The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development - the 'rich countries club') have signed a deal to make multinational firms pay tax where they really earn it. This means they should pay profit tax on all the operations in the country where their activities take place.
It will be difficult to police, and only 31 countries have signed. This means firms might just start declaring their profits in a country which has not signed. However the system they hope to implement should allow countries to demand tax on the amount of tax the firm would have made if declared correctly.
This issue has direct relevance to IB Paper 2 and for taxation policy. For VCE this is a topic that is relevant to trade and budgetary policy.
Thursday, 7 November 2013
The dangers of not competing
Qantas have announced they will stop maintaining aircraft at Avalon. Despite the protests of the engineers they have themselves to blame to some degree.
The decision will mean that part of the Qantas fleet will be maintained abroad where it is much cheaper to do so. While this is unfortunate, especially for Geelong who might welcome Australia's first nuclear power plant right now, it is an illustration of the benefits of trade.
As Qantas will be able to save money on maintenance by this move they will be able to charge lower fares. Those lower fares will benefit Qantas consumers directly and other passengers as it adds to competition in the market.
There is no point complaining about lower wages abroad or lower quality (first may be true but the second isn't). The fact is that countries should specialise in what they are comparatively best at and import the rest. In the long run nobody wins by subsidising uneconomic industries, the taxpayers and consumers pay more for a brief period of higher wages and employment for the inefficient.
The actual answer is to invest in human capital via education and training to make Australia competitive in the high tech, knowledge based industries that will allow Australians to maintain their standard of living. The alternative is to drop living standards to those of the bulk of the Asian Pacific region. There will be few takers for that.
The decision will mean that part of the Qantas fleet will be maintained abroad where it is much cheaper to do so. While this is unfortunate, especially for Geelong who might welcome Australia's first nuclear power plant right now, it is an illustration of the benefits of trade.
As Qantas will be able to save money on maintenance by this move they will be able to charge lower fares. Those lower fares will benefit Qantas consumers directly and other passengers as it adds to competition in the market.
There is no point complaining about lower wages abroad or lower quality (first may be true but the second isn't). The fact is that countries should specialise in what they are comparatively best at and import the rest. In the long run nobody wins by subsidising uneconomic industries, the taxpayers and consumers pay more for a brief period of higher wages and employment for the inefficient.
The actual answer is to invest in human capital via education and training to make Australia competitive in the high tech, knowledge based industries that will allow Australians to maintain their standard of living. The alternative is to drop living standards to those of the bulk of the Asian Pacific region. There will be few takers for that.
Labels:
Comparative advantage,
Gains from Trade,
globalisation,
International Trade,
supply side policy
Monday, 1 April 2013
Massive Holden subsidies harm consumers
It was revealed that Holden had received over $2billion in subsidies in the last 12 years, far more than previously thought.
The Australian government has long argued that subsidising industries is good for jobs in Australia. But most economists would disagree with this as both shortsighted and damaging to the economy.
The argument for subsidy relies on the idea that if it was absent then all the jobs in the industry would be lost, leading to higher unemployment and a lower standard of living in Australia.
The argument against this was first put forward by Adam Smith a then David Ricardo and has been backed up by a further 200 years of economics research. Simon Cowan of The Centre for Independent Studies has argued that if the subsidies were removed then consumers would benefit from lower car prices and the standard of living would rise as resources were redeployed to efficient industries instead.
The argument works like this:
* The car industry in Australia is uncompetitive and inefficient.
* Removing the subsidy means the industry loses money and shuts down.
* Those currently employed in car manufacturing and its supporting industries move to other sectors.
* The resources currently used up by the car industry are released for use by efficient Australian industries.
* All cars sold in Australia are imported from abroad (up from 75%) - these cost less to produce and will become cheaper as firstly the import taxes needed to protect Australian producers are scrapped and foreign producers gain economies of scale.
* Therefore consumers gain by getting their cars more cheaply (approx 1.1 million new cars are sold each year)
* Government can use the money used for subsidies to help reduce taxes or pay for other programmes such as Gonski.
Smith pointed out that competition leads to productive efficiency. Smith and Ricardo showed that with free international trade the most efficient suppliers produce the goods people want with each country specialising in the sectors they are comparatively best at. AS A RESULT EVERYONE IS BETTER OFF.
Australia has never been keen on this argument and despite reforms going back to Hawke/Keating Australia remains the most protectionist country in the G20.
The Australian government has long argued that subsidising industries is good for jobs in Australia. But most economists would disagree with this as both shortsighted and damaging to the economy.
The argument for subsidy relies on the idea that if it was absent then all the jobs in the industry would be lost, leading to higher unemployment and a lower standard of living in Australia.
The argument against this was first put forward by Adam Smith a then David Ricardo and has been backed up by a further 200 years of economics research. Simon Cowan of The Centre for Independent Studies has argued that if the subsidies were removed then consumers would benefit from lower car prices and the standard of living would rise as resources were redeployed to efficient industries instead.
The argument works like this:
* The car industry in Australia is uncompetitive and inefficient.
* Removing the subsidy means the industry loses money and shuts down.
* Those currently employed in car manufacturing and its supporting industries move to other sectors.
* The resources currently used up by the car industry are released for use by efficient Australian industries.
* All cars sold in Australia are imported from abroad (up from 75%) - these cost less to produce and will become cheaper as firstly the import taxes needed to protect Australian producers are scrapped and foreign producers gain economies of scale.
* Therefore consumers gain by getting their cars more cheaply (approx 1.1 million new cars are sold each year)
* Government can use the money used for subsidies to help reduce taxes or pay for other programmes such as Gonski.
Smith pointed out that competition leads to productive efficiency. Smith and Ricardo showed that with free international trade the most efficient suppliers produce the goods people want with each country specialising in the sectors they are comparatively best at. AS A RESULT EVERYONE IS BETTER OFF.
Australia has never been keen on this argument and despite reforms going back to Hawke/Keating Australia remains the most protectionist country in the G20.
Labels:
Budget,
International Trade,
Protection,
Subsidies,
VCE Economics
Thursday, 21 February 2013
The Asian Century
Last year the government introduced their 'Asian Century' paper. It pointed out that Australia's future lay in Asia and that the reality was that the low cost, highly innovative Asia was where world growth would be centred.
Australia has to live with this simple fact and adjust. Strangely the discussion of the paper was centred on how more language teaching was needed and how Australia had to develop new service based industries to sell to this rapidly growing industrial continent.
Virtually nobody mentioned the implied decline of low tech and manufacturing jobs in Australia. Australians are paid very well and by comparison are much less productive in terms out costs per unit than Asian economies. For many years Australia was able to maintain high manufacturing employment and let technology pass them by for decades because they were so far away.
That is no longer an option. Globalisation, which the 'Asian Century' seeks to embrace, has made the usual Australian view of ' Australian made and owned' as up to date as a dinosaur.
Australia has to learn from the successful economies of Europe. Those who held on to the old industries and work practises, such as Spain and France, have fared very badly compared to those, such as Britain, who allowed the industries to decline and shifted resources to the more modern opportunities.
The pieces linked below illustrate this. The Telstra call centres are moving to Asia where University graduates will answer your call at any time of the day or night. Telstra will cut costs, raise profits and reinvest them in the high tech sector which will provide the sustainable jobs Australia needs.
The second piece is about a US/France spat where an American industrialist declared that they would be insane to invest in France due to the poor working practises.
Trade Unions beware, protecting an inefficient job does nothing to help the future economy of any country.
Australia has to live with this simple fact and adjust. Strangely the discussion of the paper was centred on how more language teaching was needed and how Australia had to develop new service based industries to sell to this rapidly growing industrial continent.
Virtually nobody mentioned the implied decline of low tech and manufacturing jobs in Australia. Australians are paid very well and by comparison are much less productive in terms out costs per unit than Asian economies. For many years Australia was able to maintain high manufacturing employment and let technology pass them by for decades because they were so far away.
That is no longer an option. Globalisation, which the 'Asian Century' seeks to embrace, has made the usual Australian view of ' Australian made and owned' as up to date as a dinosaur.
Australia has to learn from the successful economies of Europe. Those who held on to the old industries and work practises, such as Spain and France, have fared very badly compared to those, such as Britain, who allowed the industries to decline and shifted resources to the more modern opportunities.
The pieces linked below illustrate this. The Telstra call centres are moving to Asia where University graduates will answer your call at any time of the day or night. Telstra will cut costs, raise profits and reinvest them in the high tech sector which will provide the sustainable jobs Australia needs.
The second piece is about a US/France spat where an American industrialist declared that they would be insane to invest in France due to the poor working practises.
Trade Unions beware, protecting an inefficient job does nothing to help the future economy of any country.
Labels:
Asian Century,
globalisation,
International Trade,
Supply side
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
